The Best Pie Recipes For Fall

September 28, 2026

Fall is pie season, and I will not be taking questions. Something about the cooler weather and the leaves turning makes me want to have a pie on the counter at all times, whether it’s Sunday dinner or a random Tuesday when we just need something good.

I’ve been baking pies for years, and I’ve learned that the best ones aren’t necessarily the fanciest. They’re the ones that actually turn out, that your family asks for again, and that make your house smell like you have it way more together than you actually do. These are those recipes.

This list covers everything from the classics, your apple, your pumpkin, to a few that might become new favorites.

Whether you’re baking for Thanksgiving, a fall get-together, or honestly just because it’s October, you’ll find something here worth making.

https://drdavinahseats.com/sweet-potato-pie-recipe?

Southern Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

This Southern sweet potato pie from Dr. Davinah’s Eats hits all the right notes, creamy, warmly spiced, and just sweet enough without going overboard. The filling comes together with simple pantry staples and bakes into that perfectly set, silky custard texture that makes sweet potato pie so much better than it gets credit for. A true holiday table staple.

This Sweet Potato Pie Belongs on Your Table

https://theshortordercook.com/brown-sugar-caramel-apple-pie/

Brown Sugar Caramel Apple Pie – The Short Order Cook

This Brown Sugar Caramel Apple Pie from The Short Order Cook takes the classic up a notch with a rich, buttery caramel filling that gets its depth from brown sugar instead of white. The apples stay tender without turning to mush, and that caramel soaks into every layer as it bakes. It’s the kind of pie that makes your whole kitchen smell like fall.

A Fall Pie Recipe Worth Bookmarking

https://homecookedharvest.com/pumpkin-apple-pie/

Pumpkin Apple Pie

Two fall favorites in one pie, pumpkin and spiced apple filling layered together in a flaky crust. The combination sounds unexpected but it absolutely works, and the result is something a little more interesting than your standard pumpkin pie. Bring this one to Thanksgiving and people will talk about it.

Warm Spiced Apples Meet Pumpkin Pie

https://thecookinchicks.com/apple-butter-pumpkin-pie/

Apple Butter Pumpkin Pie

Apple butter takes this pumpkin pie somewhere unexpected, deeper, fruitier, with a warmth that regular pumpkin pie just doesn’t have. The filling comes together fast, and the result tastes like it took way more effort than it did. A genuinely good twist on a fall classic.

Two Fall Classics, One Perfect Pie

https://whatagirleats.com/chocolate-chunk-pecan-pie/

Chocolate Pecan Pie

Chocolate and pecan pie together, because why choose? This one from What a Girl Eats layers rich dark chocolate chunks into the classic filling for a pie that tastes like a fudgy brownie married a pecan pie at a fall festival. It’s the kind of dessert that makes people ask for the recipe before they’ve even finished their slice.

Rich, Gooey, Completely Irresistible

https://wholenewmom.com/healthy-pumpkin-pie/

Easy Healthy Pumpkin Pie–with Unique Egg-free Option!

This healthy pumpkin pie swaps out the sugar and uses real, simple ingredients without sacrificing that classic spiced filling you want on your Thanksgiving table. The egg-free option (using chia seeds) makes it a genuine option for allergy families, not just a workaround. Bonus: it’s easy enough that you won’t dread making it.

The Egg-Free Trick Changes Everything

https://www.cookmefree.com/vegan-ginger-spiced-walnut-pear-tart/

Ginger spiced walnut pear tart

Tender pears and candied walnuts sit on a buttery, ginger-spiced crust that makes your whole kitchen smell like autumn. It’s vegan, which means Camden can dig in without any modifications, a genuine win. The filling is warmly spiced without being heavy, so it hits that sweet spot between a dessert and something you’d eat with your morning coffee.

Spiced Pears, Walnuts, Pure Magic

https://www.joinyourlife4u.com/easy-plum-custard-tart-recipe/

Easy Plum Custard Tart Recipe (Simple & Creamy) – JoinYourLife4U

This plum custard tart is exactly the kind of dessert that looks impressive but comes together without a lot of fuss. The creamy custard filling pairs beautifully with jammy, slightly tart plums, a combo that feels made for fall. It’s a great one to pull out when you want something a little more special than a standard fruit pie.

Custard Tart That Converts Non-Bakers

https://addictedtodates.com/vegan-apple-pie/

Vegan Apple Pie

This vegan apple pie from Addicted to Dates has a buttery, flaky all-shortening crust (no dairy, no eggs) and a warmly spiced filling that tastes like the real deal, because it is. The lattice top is gorgeous enough to bring to a holiday table without anyone knowing it’s accidentally allergy-friendly.

A Vegan Apple Pie Worth Bragging About

https://addictedtodates.com/vegan-pecan-pie/

Vegan Pecan Pie (No Corn Syrup)

This vegan pecan pie skips the corn syrup entirely and uses maple syrup instead, giving it a deeper, more complex sweetness that honestly makes it hard to go back to the original. It’s also completely dairy- and egg-free, which means Camden can have a slice right alongside everyone else at the table. The filling is gloriously gooey, the crust is flaky, and nobody will know the difference.

Yes, Vegan Pie Can Taste This Good

https://earthly-provisions.com/vegan-pumpkin-pie/

Vegan Pumpkin Pie

This vegan pumpkin pie from Earthly Provisions skips the eggs and dairy without sacrificing that classic silky, spiced filling we all look forward to every November. The coconut milk base gives it a rich, creamy texture that honestly holds its own against any traditional version. A total win if you’re baking for a crowd with mixed dietary needs.

This Fall Pie Recipe Is Dairy-Free

https://semihomemadekitchen.com/no-bake-cranberry-pie/

No-Bake Cranberry Pie

This no-bake cranberry pie comes together with a graham cracker crust and a creamy, tart cranberry filling that sets up in the fridge, no oven required. It’s the one to bring when you want something a little unexpected on the holiday table without spending your whole afternoon in the kitchen.

Skip the Oven, Keep the Wow

https://thebutteryfairytale.com/3-ingredient-peanut-butter-pie/

BEST 3 Ingredient Peanut Butter Pie No Bake Filling Recipe

Creamy, rich, and shockingly simple, this no-bake peanut butter pie filling comes together with just three ingredients and zero oven time. It’s the kind of dessert that looks like you tried way harder than you did, which is exactly what we need heading into the busy fall season.

Creamy, No-Bake, Only 3 Ingredients

Final Thoughts!

Fall pie baking doesn’t have to be complicated or perfect to be worth doing. The recipes I’ve shared are the ones I actually come back to, the ones that have survived busy weeks, picky eaters, and more than a few moments where I questioned my crust choices. They work, and they’re good, and that’s really all a pie needs to be.

If you’re putting together your baking list for the season, I hope this roundup of the best pie recipes for fall gives you a solid starting point, or at least one new recipe to try. There’s something really satisfying about pulling a pie out of the oven and knowing your people are going to love it, even on a regular Tuesday in October.

If you make one (or a few), I’d genuinely love to hear how it goes, drop a comment below and tell me which one you tried. And if you want to save this for later when you’re deep in fall baking mode and need something to make this weekend, go ahead and pin it. It’ll be here when you need it.

Like my content? Check out my Instagram!

Check Out These Pins!

Fall Pie Recipes Your Whole Family Will Love

The Only Fall Pie Recipes You Need This Year

Lexie Noelle Undem

I'm Lexie, and The Undem Family Adventures is where our real life shows up. You'll find easy, allergy-friendly recipes, family travel, gentle parenting, crafts, and the little systems that keep us going.